ASHINGTON, Sept. 29
— The Central Intelligence Agency secretly began to send teams of
American officers to northern Afghanistan about three years ago in
an attempt to persuade the leader of the anti- Taliban Afghan
opposition to capture and perhaps kill Osama bin Laden, according to
American intelligence officials.
The covert effort, which has not been previously disclosed, was
based on an attempt to work with Ahmed Shah Massoud, who was then
the military leader of the largest anti- Taliban group in the
northern mountains of Afghanistan, and to have his forces go after
Mr. bin Laden. Mr. Massoud was himself fatally wounded only two days
before the attacks on the Pentagon and the World Trade Center, and
the C.I.A. believes that he was assassinated by members of Mr. bin
Laden's organization.
The C.I.A.'s clandestine efforts to deal with Mr. Massoud were
among the most sensitive and highly classified elements of a broader
long-term campaign, continuing unsuccessfully through the end of the
Clinton administration and into the Bush administration, to destroy
Mr. bin Laden's terrorist network. The American campaign against Mr.
bin Laden intensified after the August 1998 bombings of two United
States Embassies in East Africa, which transformed the Saudi-born
exile into America's most wanted terrorist.
Today, the hunt for Osama bin Laden and his lieutenants in Al
Qaeda, the terrorist network he leads from his sanctuary in
Afghanistan, has escalated to wartime levels. The Bush
administration is considering a full range of overt and covert
military and intelligence proposals that Washington policy makers
would have considered too risky or unworkable before the attacks on
the World Trade Center and the Pentagon.
But according to current and former intelligence officials and
other policy makers, the United States has been trying to kill bin
Laden and destroy Al Qaeda for years, as the terrorist organization
has become more ruthless and ambitious in its efforts to attack
American interests around the world.
Clinton administration lawyers determined that the United States
could legitimately seek to kill Mr. bin Laden and his lieutenants
despite the presidential ban on assassinations, according to current
and former American officials. The lawyers concluded that efforts to
hunt and kill Mr. bin Laden were defensible either as acts of war or
as national self defense, legitimate under both American and
international law. As a result, President Clinton did not waive the
executive order banning assassinations.
There have been an array of unsuccessful attempts to target Mr.
bin Laden and disrupt or destroy Al Qaeda, American officials say.
The Clinton administration even considered mounting a secret effort
to steal millions of dollars from the bin Laden terrorist network by
siphoning it out of the international financial system, but
discarded the scheme because of objections from the United States
Treasury about the implications for world finance.
The United States launched cruise missiles against a meeting Mr.
bin Laden was believed to be attending, encouraged Mr. Massoud and
other Afghan leaders to try to capture him, and received a secret
report from one Afghan group last year about its failed attempt to
assassinate Mr. bin Laden.
The United States also led an international effort to shut down
Afghanistan's airline, which American intelligence officials
believed was being used by Al Qaeda to ship money and personnel
around the world, while also pressuring other nations to arrest and
disrupt Al Qaeda cells.
"This was a top priority for us over the past several years, and
not a day went by when we didn't press as hard as we could," said
Samuel R. Berger, national security adviser in the Clinton
administration. "But this is a tough, tough problem. I think we were
pushing it as hard as we could. And I think the Bush administration
is handling it in a smart way."
But until the devastating attacks on New York and Washington, the
American-led efforts to hunt Mr. bin Laden lacked the sense of
urgency that prevails today. American intelligence and law
enforcement officials grew complacent about the threat of a domestic
attack by Al Qaeda, failed by their own admission to share
information adequately or coordinate their efforts, and were caught
by surprise on Sept. 11.
Washington did not build a strong international coalition to
focus on defeating Al Qaeda, which was seen by other nations largely
as an American problem. Banks in Europe and the Middle East
repeatedly balked at American pressure to cut off Al Qaeda
financing, while wealthy individuals in Persian Gulf states —
sometimes in the guise of donating to Islamic charities — continued
to provide financial support to Al Qaeda.
At the same time, Al Qaeda was rapidly evolving into a larger and
more complex terrorist threat, making it difficult for the United
States to keep up with its scope and abilities. Mr. bin Laden's
great achievement within the terrorist world has been to forge
alliances with other Islamic extremist groups under the umbrella of
Al Qaeda, providing them financing, training and a sanctuary in
Afghanistan, while encouraging coordinated action.
The United States had only a hazy understanding of Mr. bin
Laden's growing significance before 1996, when an Al Qaeda insider,
Jamal Ahmed Al-Fadl, defected to the United States and began to
describe the extent of Mr. bin Laden's plans and objectives. Based
largely on Mr. al- Fadl's information, a federal grand jury indicted
Mr. bin Laden on terrorist conspiracy charges in June 1998, just two
months before the twin bombings of the American Embassies in Kenya
and Tanzania.
The embassy bombings forced Washington to recognize that Mr. bin
Laden had become a major national security threat. Sometime after
the bombings, the C.I.A. began its efforts to work with Mr. Massoud
against Mr. bin Laden, American officials said.
The officials declined to provide many details of the effort. But
officials say that C.I.A. officers secretly traveled to Mr.
Massoud's mountain stronghold in northern Afghanistan and opened
talks in an effort to fashion an anti-bin Laden alliance.