INTERESTING TIMES: Design to win
By Saul Singer | September, 16 2001 |
(September 16) The day after, I had the same traumatic, disoriented feeling I
had after my brother fell in battle and after Yitzhak Rabin's assassination. How
could the sun still be shining? How can daily life just continue as if nothing
happened? The sickening scenes of the collapsing twin towers and the gaping hole
left in their place did not just terrorize America, but us, sitting here in
Jerusalem. It was a successful attack on the entire world.
Terror must
be understood as the most potent form of psychological warfare. Terrorism is a
way of bypassing the armies that countries build to defend themselves and
directly attacking the morale of the enemy. Terrorists know that the ability to
fight is irrelevant if the will to fight has been defeated.
If we think
of the fight against terrorism only in military terms, we have fallen into their
trap. Israelis show instinctive understanding of this when they fight back by
continuing with their normal lives. Workers labored around the clock to reopen
Jerusalem's Sbarro pizzeria (devastated by a suicide bombing a month ago) as
quickly as possible . The reopening this week was an occasion of pride and
defiance, attended by President Moshe Katsav and United States Ambassador Daniel
Kurtzer.
Most Americans, like Israelis, will have the instinct to deny
terrorism the victory of affecting their way of life, but this instinct must be
cultivated and reinforced. President George W. Bush, unfortunately, displayed a
blindness to this psychological aspect of the fight against terrorism when he
let his security people keep him away from the White House.
The
president, as the explanation goes, was shuttled from one place to another,
including a nuclear missile base in Nebraska, because of unnamed threats against
the White House and Air Force One. This is not convincing.
There is no
doubt that Air Force One could have been more than adequately defended by a
fighter jet escort; the same is the case for the White House itself.
Grounding every American civilian airliner, closing the borders, sending
the president into bunkers, all these are victories for the terrorists. The
actions taken on the civilian side were perhaps necessary precautions, but the
president should not have been swayed from his path by a single inch.
The generals were thinking about how to maximize the security of the
president, but by ignoring the psychological aspect, they unnecessarily weakened
America's national security.
THE CHOICE of where to fly Air Force One
was just the first of many that will demand understanding of the psychology of
terror. It is not too late for Bush to learn from his mistake. Indeed, he must,
because the president bears great responsibility for setting America's mood, and
by extension, the mood of the world.
It is not enough to say, over and
over again, that America's spirit will not be broken; what matters is acting
that way. The twin towers were not just a financial center. They were, as George
Will writes, "like Manhattan itself, architectural expressions of the vigor of
American civilization."
President Bush should announce a national
competition to design a new World Trade Center, with the stipulation that the
new center capture the soaring spirit of the towers that were destroyed, and of
America's belief in itself and the new age.
There will be those who
advocate a squat, secure, structure that can withstand the impact of numerous
hijacked planes. The winning design should be exactly the opposite: a complex
designed for a world that has defeated terrorism, not one that has been cowed by
it.
There are 189 members of the United Nations. Roughly five of them
use terrorism as an instrument of national policy. America's goal should be to
reduce the number of governments that support terrorism to zero by the time the
new soaring, wispy, inspiring World Trade Center is rebuilt.
This goal
may sound utopian, but it is both realistic and necessary. If we accept the
inevitability of terrorist states, we are dooming ourselves to a futile attempt
at turning our cities into bunkers. This time the weapon was hijacked airplanes
- a weapon so low-tech that it could have been used in the 1940s. We know that
the technology is already available to make September 11 look like child's play.
The United States alone, the 184 non-terrorist states together, or some
combination in between, have the might to make it impossible for a handful of
tin-pot dictatorships to sow terror and remain in power. The first step is for
America to show that it is not only saying it is unbowed, but has set a deadline
for and is betting on its own victory.
saul@jpost.co.il
This article can also be read at http://www.jpost.com/Editions/2001/09/16/Columns/Columns.34885.html